Thursday, May 10, 2012

Breeding the Next Generation of Doctors Through the Television Screen: Surgery on the Wii Remote

Last weekend I performed several surgeries on heavily traumatized patients, with my work ranging from pulling bullet shards out of a beating heart to extracting tumors from an older gentlemen’s abdomen.

“Trauma Center New Blood”, a surgical simulation game designed by ATLUS for the Nintendo DS and the Wii, has four titles released currently in America: Trauma Center: Under the Knife, Trauma Center: Second Opinion, Trauma Center: Under the Knife 2, and Trauma Center: New Blood, with a new title, Trauma Team, recently released. This game simulates the tension and pressures of performing surgeries on patients who have undergone various traumas or accidents. One such accident encountered in the early stages of the game involves the hospital director collapsing, and after basic examinations, it is revealed that the director had several tumors on his lower stomach and intestinal tracts ("Mahalo: Learn Anything").

To remove the tumors, I used what the game referred to as the Powell Procedure, which is the “Trauma Center” standard procedure for the removal of tumors. This procedure involves first locating the tumors using a small ultrasound, removing the tissue above the tumor, reducing the tumor size by draining the its cytoplasm, and then using a scalpel to excise the tumor from the surrounding tissues. Forceps are then employed to remove the tumor and when it has been successfully removed, a gauze-like synthetic membrane covers and closes the wound so you can move on to the other tumors quickly. Smaller tumors surrounding the main masses are burnt away with a laser.

After successfully completing the procedure and undergoing copious amounts of stress as a result (all procedures in the game are timed, and if the Powell procedure is not completed quickly in the game, more cytoplasm builds up in areas surrounding the tumors, forcing you to redo the procedure when it does), I began to think about the feasibility of such a procedure as it relates to the removal of cancerous tumors. While imaginative and seemingly realistic, the Powell procedure appears to be a product of the game makers’ imagination as very little record of the procedure exists in credible sources.
In the real world, surgery has several functions in cancer treatment including diagnostic, curative, preventative, palliative, restorative, and supportive (“wikiCancer”). The type of surgery suggested in the Wii game is a curative surgery, as it removes a sizable mass from the infected organ in an attempt to remove or destroy the cancer. More specifically, “Trauma Center” demonstrates excisional surgery, using a scalpel to physically remove the entire tumor, and laser surgery, using concentrated light to burn away infected cells. These categories of surgery are very general, however, and they are often classified more specific terms to refer to the organ in question and methods of entry. (For example, spinal tumors are referred to in different terms than pituitary tumors).

For the removal of stomach cancers, a procedure called endoscopic mucosal resection is often employed. This procedure involves the removal of tumors from the inside lining of the stomach, and it is often limited by the size of the tumors and by the extent to which they have grown/ metastasized (“Mayo Clinic” Stomach Cancer). This type of surgical procedure often involves the removal of normal, non-cancerous, cells surrounding the tumor in order to ensure complete removal, but, although thorough removal of a tumor through surgery can be effective, it is more often not the only tactic employed to fight cancer.
In the “Trauma Center” there was no mention of follow up procedures or alternative means of combatting the tumors, an aspect which surprised me as the removal of the physical mass may not be sufficient and the lack of follow-up or use of radiation or other medications may increase likelihood of cancer return.  In a 2006 study presented at the Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium, cancer survivability and mortality rates show a significant increase when surgical treatments are combined with chemotherapy and radiation therapy treatments, with a median survival period of 4.5 years for patients treated with chemotherapy/radiation/surgery, compared 1.8 years for those treated with surgery alone in a study comparing 14 patients treated with chemotherapy and radiation and 17 patients treated with surgery alone. In"Trimodality therapy is superior to surgery alone in esophageal cancer." researchers concluded that chemotherapy and radiation therapy prior to surgery appears to improve survival compared with surgery alone in the treatment of esophageal cancer (Krasna). Based on the small variable and control populations discussed in the study (totaling 31 individuals), the study seems limited and the results may be affected by the small sample population. Previous trials mentioned have also produced conflicting results, suggesting that further research may be necessary and that options for treatment are better determined on a patient by patient basis with personalized treatment.

So, in conclusion, surgery is an effective means of cancer treatment in most cases, but is suggested to be more effective when done in conjunction with chemotherapy and radiation treatment. The “Trauma Center” Wii game, while not a true representation of how tumors are removed from the stomach and intestinal tracts does promote surgery as an effective treatment I the removal of cancerous masses. For the aspiring pre-meds, the game is fast paced and stressful, especially as the patients vitals begin to crash and the Wii remote refuses to hold still or cut as a real scalpel would. It is not very realistic in its depiction of treatments or scenarios for how patients end up in the hospital (ex: pulling a bullet out of someone’s heart), but it is a fun game to play late at night while waiting for Bronco delivery.

References:
"Endoscopic mucosal resection." Mayo Clinic. Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research, 02 Aug 2011. Web. 1 May 2012. <http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/endoscopic-mucosal-resection/MY00813/>.

Krasna, M.. "Trimodality therapy is superior to surgery alone in esophageal cancer." ASCO.org. American Society of Clinical Oncology, 2006. Web. 1 May 2012.

"Stomach Cancer." Mayo Clinic. Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research, 02 Aug 2011. Web. 1 May 2012. <http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/stomach-cancer/DS00301/DSECTION=treatments-and-drugs>.

"Trauma Center: New Blood Walkthrough - Chapter 1 - Northern Lights." Mahalo: Learn Anything. Mahalo.com incorperated, 2012. Web. 1 May 2012. <http://www.mahalo.com/trauma-center-new-blood-walkthrough-chapter-1-northern-lights/>.
"Types of Surgery- wikiCancer." wikiCancer. Wiki, 2012. Web. 1 May 2012. <http://www.wikicancer.org/page/Types of surgery>.